Skip to main content
Logo
Home

Ask a Question

Log In/Register
Logo

Mega Nav

  • Publication Success
    • Academic Editing Services Editing and proofreading services for a publication-ready manuscript
    • Publication Support Services Customized service packs to match all publication needs
    • Translation Services Expert help for all academic translation needs
    • Statistical Analysis and Review Services Comprehensive statistical support to getting published
  • Get Published
    • Conducting Research
      • Research Data Management
      • Publication Planning
    • Manuscript Writing
      • Academic Writing
      • Research Paper Structure
    • Journal Selection
      • Choosing a Journal
      • Publication Models
    • Journal Submission & Peer Review
      • Manuscript Submission
      • Tracking Your Submission
      • Responding to Reviewer Comments
      • Journal Rejection
      • Journal Retraction
  • Career Growth
    • Securing Research Funding
      • Funding Sources
      • Grant Application
    • Science Communication
      • Public Engagement
      • Plain Language Summaries
      • Video & Graphical Abstracts
      • Promoting Your Research
    • Professional Development
      • Collaboration and networking
      • Presentation Skills
      • Project Management
    • Career Advancement
      • Becoming a Peer Reviewer
      • Career Advice for researchers
  • Mental Health
    • Mental Health in Academia
      • Research Culture
      • Researcher Wellness
      • Daily Motivation for Researchers
    • Stories by Researchers
      • Explore Other Themes
      • Mental Health In Academia
      • Motivational Stories
      • Stories Of Struggle
  • Q&A
  • Researchers & Their Stories
  • More
    Recent Webinar
    29 June 2021
    Experiential Live Edit: How to improve Biomed manuscripts
    View Details
    • workshop
      • Webinars & Workshops
      • News & Trends
      • Videos
      • Trending Research
    • Trends
      • Industry Interviews
      • Recommended Reads
      • Infographics
  • English Editing
    • English Editing Overview
    • Advanced Editing
    • Premium Editing
    • Scientific Editing
  • Translation Services
  • PSS Packs
    • PSS Packs Overview
    • Silver Pack
    • Gold Pack
    • Platinum Pack
    • Custom Pack

Profile Picture

Terry Monahan

Profile

Bio

Subject Matter Expertise

Forum Engagements

Questions Asked

Questions Answered

Questions Followed

Profile
Questions Asked
Questions Answered
Questions Followed

Q: What are the components of a good review?

Detailed question-

Reviewers can request CME credit, but to award it their reviews must be considered thorough and complete. What are the components of a thorough and complete review (…
  • Asked by Terry Monahan on April 4, 2016

1 Answer

According to the Council of Science Editors’ white paper on publication ethics, a peer reviewer’s responsibilities include:

Providing…
Answer
Follow this Question

About Editage Insights

Editage Insights offers a wealth of free academic research and publishing resources and is a one-stop guide for authors and others involved in scholarly publishing. Our original resources for authors and journals will help you become an expert in academic publishing. Register for comprehensive research tips and expert advice on English writing, journal publishing, good publication practices, trends in publishing, and a lot more.

More

Become a Member

Contribute as a Guest

Contact Us

Subscribe

 
Read Editage Insights in your favorite RSS Reader.

Follow us on social platforms

 
 
 
 
 

Editage Insights Global Sites

Japanese – エディテージ・インサイト

Simplified Chinese – 意得辑专家视点

Korean - 에디티지 인사이트

Editage

  • About Editage
  • Contact Editage
  • News
  • Payment Options
  • Prices for Editing

Publication Support Services

  • Artwork Preparation
  • Journal Selection
  • Journal Submission
  • Plagiarism Check
  • Publication Support Packs
  • Rapid Technical Review
  • Resubmission Support
  • Statistical Analysis and Review Services

Quality

  • Confidentiality
  • Publication Ethics
  • Quality Assurance
  • Testimonials

Editing Services

  • Advanced Editing
  • Digital Editing
  • English Editing Services
  • Post-Editing Services
  • Premium Editing
  • Scientific Editing

Our Expertise

  • Business and Economics
  • Life Sciences
  • Medical Sciences
  • Physical Sciences
  • Social Sciences

Full disclosure: Editage Insights is a product of Editage, a Cactus Communications brand that offers expert services and AI tools for all academia on one platform.

English Editing -  Editage.com | 英文校正 – Editage.jp | 원어민영문교정 – Editage.co.kr | SCI英文论文发表 – Editage.cn | publicação de artigos – Editage.com.br | 編輯英文 – Editage.com.tw | English Editing Services

Trending Searches

  • Statement of the problem
  • COVID-19
  • Background of study
  • Scope of the study
  • Types of qualitative research
  • Rationale of the study
  • Concept paper
  • Literature review
  • Introduction in research
  • Under "Editor Evaluation"
  • Ethics in research
See more
See less

Recent Searches

  • Review paper
  • Responding to reviewer comments
  • Predatory publishers
  • Scope and delimitations
  • Open access
  • Plagiarism in research
  • Journal selection tips
  • Editor assigned
  • Types of articles
  • "Reject and Resubmit" status
  • Decision in process
  • Conflict of interest
See more
See less

Recommended Courses

Recommended Courses

  • Journal Publication
How to avoid retractions and publish…
Editage Insights
LEARNING TIME
6 hrs
LECTURES
4
 approx. 90 min each
  • Journal Publication
How to be effective at formal…
Editage Insights
LEARNING TIME
2 hrs
LECTURES
13
 approx. 9 min each
Show all