Q: Status immediately changed from With Editor to Required Reviews Completed

Detailed question-

Hello! I submitted my manuscript to an Elsevier journal 6 months ago. After the 1st round of review one of the reviewers rejected the manuscript and subsequently the paper was rejected by the…

1 Answer

Thank you for your question.

Since the resubmission of your manuscript after…

Answer

Q: The status has been "with editor" for 2 months

Detailed question-

Hello. I submitted a manuscript to a high index journal four months ago. After about a month the reviewers suggested minor revisions and rejection and subsequently the editor rejected the paper.…

1 Answer

Thank you for your question. We understand that the status of the manuscript has not changed for 2 months after resubmission…

Answer

Q: What does it mean if my revised manuscript has been at Required Reviews Completed for three weeks?

Detailed question-

Hello, everyone. I submitted my manuscript to an Elsevier journal in January 2020. After 10 months, I received a major revision and a minor revision decision by the [two] reviewers. One-and-a-half…

1 Answer

Required Reviews Completed by itself does not mean anything good or bad. It simply means, as the…

Answer