Why There Are So Many Different Style Guides

Have you ever wondered why there are so many different style guides? Why can't all publishers just follow one style guide to make life easier for editors and researchers? I had this question too, and here's what I found out. 

Academic journal style guides are used to ensure that research papers are formatted consistently and accurately. They also help to facilitate communication between researchers by providing a common set of conventions for citing sources and presenting data.  

The most used style guides are the Publication Manual of the American Psychological Association (APA), the Modern Language Association's (MLA) Handbook, and the Chicago Manual of Style (CMOS). Each of these style guides has its own strengths and weaknesses, and the best choice for a particular paper will depend on the discipline and the journal to which it is being submitted. 

For example, the APA style guide is widely used in the social sciences, natural sciences, and health sciences and is known for its clear and concise formatting. The MLA style guide is more commonly used in the humanities and emphasizes the importance of citing sources in detail. The CMOS style guide is a comprehensive guide to all aspects of publishing, from manuscript preparation to typography. 

In addition to these three major style guides, there are also several discipline-specific style guides. For example, the Council of Biology Editors (CBE) Style Manual is used in the biological sciences, and the American Medical Association (AMA) Manual of Style is used in medicine. 

Now, in addition to these common style manuals, publishers also develop in-house style manuals, which are mostly loosely based on the common style manuals. For example, Elsevier journals have their own style guides. There are advantages to having publisher-specific style guides. These guides can be more specific to the needs of the publisher's journals, and they can also be updated more frequently to reflect changes in the field. A publisher might have a particular focus on a particular discipline or field, and they might want to develop a style guide that is tailored to the specific needs of that discipline. Additionally, a publisher might have a particular house style that they want to maintain across all their publications. Even within the same discipline, different publishers may have different preferences for how research papers are formatted and cited. This is why it is important to check the publisher's style guide before submitting a paper. Additionally, publisher-specific style guides can help to create a sense of identity for the publisher's journals and make them stand out from other publications. 

It is true that having so many different style guides can be inconvenient for editors and researchers. However, it is also important to remember that style guides serve an important purpose. They help to ensure that research papers are clear, consistent, and accurate. By following a style guide, authors can make their work easier to read and understand, and they can help to ensure that their work is properly cited and attributed. 

Want to ensure that your manuscript is highly readable, consistent, and free of any typos and grammatical errors? Try Editage’s copyediting service, where a professional academic editor performs a thorough check of the language and style used in your article.